Advertisement
Wednesday, January 14, 2026

Opinion: To fix Canada, we must fix our troubled stock market

Date:

Revitalizing Canada’s Economy Starts With Fixing the TSX

For decades, the Toronto Stock Exchange (TSX) stood as a proud symbol of Canadian economic might. It was the gateway to funding for the nation’s industrial titans, from towering banks and sprawling energy firms to world-leading miners. It channeled the savings of millions into the engines of national growth. Yet, a quiet but profound concern is now spreading among investors, entrepreneurs, and policymakers: the TSX is not just underperforming; it is failing to fulfill its core mandate of financing Canada’s future.

While global markets surge, driven by innovation in technology and green energy, Canada’s premier exchange feels increasingly sidelined. This isn’t merely a problem for portfolio managers seeking returns. It is a fundamental threat to Canadian prosperity, signaling a dearth of new, high-growth companies and a worrying reliance on legacy industries. To reignite broad-based economic dynamism, Canada must first confront the challenges plaguing its public capital markets.

The Symptom: A Market Lagging Behind the Future

The evidence of the TSX’s struggle is visible in the numbers and the narrative. The exchange remains heavily concentrated in financials, energy, and materials—sectors that, while historically vital, are not the primary drivers of 21st-century growth.

A Concentration Crisis

  • Over-Reliance on Old Economy Sectors: A staggering portion of the TSX’s valuation is tied to resources and banking. This leaves the market—and by extension, the retirement savings of countless Canadians—highly exposed to commodity price cycles and interest rate fluctuations.
  • The “Missing Middle” of Growth: Compared to the U.S., Canada has a glaring shortage of publicly listed companies in high-growth sectors like technology, biotechnology, and advanced manufacturing. We excel at starting innovative firms but often fail to scale them into global champions on our own exchange.
  • Liquidity and Valuation Gaps: Many TSX-listed companies, especially smaller caps, suffer from thin trading volumes. This lack of liquidity discourages large institutional investors, leading to lower valuations than comparable firms might receive on U.S. exchanges like the NASDAQ.
  • This creates a vicious cycle: promising companies see a better path to capital and recognition south of the border, so they list there or get acquired early, further draining the TSX of its growth potential.

    The Root Causes: Why the TSX is Falling Short

    Diagnosing the problem requires looking beyond simple performance charts. Structural and regulatory issues have made the public markets a less attractive destination for both companies and investors.

    For Companies, Going Public Has Lost Its Luster

  • Regulatory Burden and Cost: The process of an initial public offering (IPO) in Canada is seen as expensive and laden with complex, ongoing compliance requirements. For a growing CEO, this administrative headache can outweigh the benefits of public capital.
  • The Lure of Private Capital: Venture capital and private equity have grown exponentially, offering ambitious companies large funding rounds without the scrutiny, volatility, and reporting demands of the public markets. Why go public when you can stay private longer?
  • Smaller Homegrown Analyst Coverage: With many brokerages reducing their research teams, smaller TSX listings can become “orphaned,” receiving little to no analyst attention. This invisibility stifles investor interest and liquidity.
  • For Investors, Options Feel Limited

  • Pension Funds Looking Abroad: Canada’s massive pension funds, some of the largest in the world, are mandated to seek the best risk-adjusted returns. Often, they find those opportunities not on the TSX, but in global private and public markets, inadvertently starving domestic listings of anchor investment.
  • The ETF Exodus: The rise of low-cost exchange-traded funds (ETFs) has been a boon for investors, but many of the most popular funds track U.S. or global indices. This passively funnels Canadian savings directly into foreign companies.
  • Perception of Stagnation: The collective narrative of a “resource-heavy” and “low-growth” market becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy, deterring a new generation of investors seeking exposure to disruptive trends.
  • The Path Forward: A Blueprint for a Relevant TSX

    Revitalizing the TSX is not about propping up old industries; it’s about aggressively building the bridge between Canadian capital and Canadian innovation. It requires a concerted effort from regulators, listed companies, and the investment community.

    1. Modernize Regulation to Encourage Listings

    Streamlining the IPO process and ongoing reporting for emerging companies is critical. Exploring models like a “venture segment” with tailored rules could make public capital a more viable, attractive growth step. The goal is to make listing a competitive advantage, not a bureaucratic penalty.

    2. Incentivize Long-Term Domestic Investment

    Policies should encourage patient Canadian capital to back Canadian growth. This could involve:

  • Examining tax structures to make long-term investment in domestic public companies more attractive.
  • Fostering greater collaboration between pension funds and the ecosystem of scaling Canadian firms.
  • Supporting initiatives that boost analyst coverage and market-making for small and mid-cap TSX listings.
  • 3. Cultivate the Ecosystem from Start to Scale

    A vibrant public market needs a robust pipeline. This means:

  • Doubling down on venture capital to fuel the start-up stage.
  • Creating better pathways for those successful start-ups to scale up domestically before considering a sale or foreign listing.
  • Celebrating and promoting the success stories that do choose the TSX, building a new narrative of innovation and opportunity.
  • 4. Embrace the Energy Transition as a Growth Catalyst

    Canada doesn’t need to abandon its resource expertise; it needs to evolve it. The TSX can become the global financing hub for the next wave of energy—critical minerals, hydrogen, carbon capture, and clean tech. This leverages existing knowledge while decisively pivoting toward the future.

    A Strong TSX is the Foundation of a Strong Canada

    Fixing the TSX is not a narrow financial exercise. It is an economic imperative. A dynamic, innovative, and globally competitive stock exchange performs essential functions: it provides companies with the fuel to expand and invent, offers citizens a stake in national prosperity through their investments, and signals to the world that Canada is open for the business of the future.

    The choice is clear. We can accept a gradual decline into economic irrelevance, anchored to the commodities of the past. Or, we can undertake the necessary reforms to rebuild our public market into a true engine of growth. By making the TSX a magnet for the world’s most ambitious companies and the capital that seeks them, we don’t just boost portfolio returns—we invest in the very future of the Canadian economy. The path to national prosperity, indeed, starts here.

    Miles Keaton
    Miles Keaton is a Canadian journalist and opinion columnist with 9+ years of experience analyzing national affairs, civil infrastructure, mobility trends, and economic policy. He earned his Communications and Public Strategy degree from the prestigious Dalhousie University and completed advanced studies in media and political economy at the selective York University. Miles writes thought-provoking opinion pieces that provide insight and perspective on Canada’s evolving social, political, and economic landscape.

    LEAVE A REPLY

    Please enter your comment!
    Please enter your name here

    Share post:

    Subscribe

    Advertisement

    Popular

    More like this
    Related

    70,000 federal workers to get details on new early-retirement plan in Canada

    Canada's New Early Retirement Offer for 70,000 Federal Workers...

    Spotify reveals Canada’s top-streamed artists, songs and albums of 2025

    Canada's Top Spotify Artists and Songs of 2025 Revealed:...

    U.S. producers criticize Trump’s tariffs during hearing on trade deal with Canada, Mexico

    U.S. Industry Leaders Oppose Tariffs in USMCA Trade Deal...

    Flood clean up a ‘total nightmare’, says business

    Navigating Business Flood Cleanup: A Survival Guide After Disaster The...